No way this is going to fail miserably
Not when everyone gets an A!
Your i is upside down
A¡ mine is off center.
Your keming is off
I can’t tell if that’s a typo or a joke about your leading
It was a kerny joke about how in most fonts the r and n together read as an m, which is about kerning again.
Oops, I remembered them backwards. I thought kerning was vertical spacing and leading was horizontal. You’d think I’d remember that from the typography class that I failed.
Turns out that I was too incorrect to appreciate your joke. I appreciate it now, but can’t bring myself to laugh at it since it’s now saturated in my embarrassment. But your pun got a good chuckle out of me!
Traditionally, these pilot programs operate as a marketing program rather than an educational program.
You’re going to see a class of students enter the system with enormous supplemental aid and resources. The AI will be included but largely incidental. The students will be cherry-picked for media optics, rather than randomly selected from within the school district. Tons of paid professionals will write long-winded hagiographies about the affordability and effectiveness of the program. Some Ivy League University or Fortune 500 business will make a big show of admitting the most charismatic and saleable student graduates.
Then the program will be rolled out to the rest of the country as quickly and sloppily as possible. AI will be jammed down people’s throats. You’ll get an earful about stupid idiot parents hysterically complaining about their dumb baby children, because they’re afraid of The Terminator movies. This will be book-ended with Steven Pinker and Bill Gates calmly explaining how AI turns dumbies into geniuses. A string of movies and TV shows will be released about kids getting AI education and becoming too smart (and time traveling or getting magic powers or some other silly bullshit).
The YIMBY coalition of very informed TV nerds will be assembled to scream at anyone who doesn’t like AI. If you don’t like AI you’re Ableist or a Bigot or Not Serious About Education. Meanwhile, we’ll get an earful about how certain migrants and POCs are incapable of learning from AI because of their inferior genes. School districts will be told to either adopt AI or lose their funding / get taken over by the state / federal agencies. National media will be saturated with “AI is normal” media content until people stop resisting.
And all of this will culminate in more school privatization, more public education defunding, and more militant policing of young people. Because that’s always been the real end goal.
Imagine paying $55,000/year to make your child a statistic in a marketing campaign
Data says otherwise.
What data?
That kid may not be old enough to get this
He can ask his LLM to explain it to him.
Great, even less educated students coming out of this one.
It’ll probably cost more then just using teachers too.
That’s not what the data says. These kids are going to outpace traditional learning kids by miles.
Is this data in the room with us?
- “AI should serve as a scaffold for cognitive construction rather than a substitute.”
- “…the teacher’s role is shifting from knowledge transmission to instructional design and behavioral facilitation… Teachers must develop digital literacy and data fluency while acting as safeguards against over‑automation, ensuring that human judgment and educational values mediate AI adoption.”
- “…while AI offers efficiency and feedback advantages, traditional teaching remains essential for tasks requiring cultural interpretation, discourse depth, and emotional connection. A blended model—AI for repetitive or procedural tasks and teachers for critical discourse—appears most effective.”
This study explicitly does not advocate for replacing teachers with AI, and repeatedly cautions against doing so
You have to excuse them, they used AI to summarize it.
Ironically… so did I 🙃 But I hand-verified everything it said, and adjusted the quotes.
And the school that is opening will still have human “guides” so I’m curious how it will work out. I agree it should be a mix of AI and human, and not fully AI.
These findings highlight both the promise and the limitations of AI in language education, underscoring the importance of teacher facilitation and thoughtful design of human–AI interaction to support deep and sustainable learning.
The problem is there’s no teachers in this scenario, at least that’s my understanding
You’re right, they will have “guides” instead of teachers. This might be to far, but we won’t know until they try it. A mix of human and AI teachers would probably be best.
Really? Because the data I’ve seen says the exact opposite and that Gen Z is the first generation of people dumber than the generation before them. These kids are already fucked and AI is going to make it even worse.
I’ve seen says the exact opposite and that Gen Z is the first generation of people dumber than the generation before them.
Do you have a citation for this?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Post
The New York Post (NY Post), founded as the New York Evening Post (originally New-York Evening Post), is an American conservative[3] daily tabloid newspaper published in New York City. Th
The Post has been criticized since the beginning of Murdoch’s ownership for sensationalism, blatant advocacy, and conservative bias. In 1980, the Columbia Journalism Review stated that the “New York Post is no longer merely a journalistic problem. It is a social problem—a force for evil.”[9] The Post has been accused of contorting its news coverage to suit Murdoch’s business needs, in particular avoiding subjects which could be unflattering to the government of the People’s Republic of China, where Murdoch has invested heavily in satellite television.[63]
On October 14, 2020, three weeks before the 2020 United States presidential election, the Post published a front-page story purporting to reveal “smoking gun” emails recovered from a laptop abandoned by Hunter Biden at a computer repair store in Wilmington, Delaware.[105] The only sources named in the story were Trump personal attorney Rudy Giuliani and strategy advisor Steve Bannon.[105] The story came under heavy criticism from other news sources and anonymous reporters at the Post itself for “flimsy” reporting, including questions about the reliability of its sourcing and the lack of outreach to either Hunter Biden or the Joe Biden campaign for pre-publication comment.[106][107]
Right wing tabloid, you fell for republican propaganda.
That was just the first news link I grabbed about the topic. You want a different news site? There’s plenty. Or maybe a link directly to the study that’s also in this article?
Sure, anything is better than a tabloid that supports Trump.
EDIT: So no proof that isn’t from a right wing propaganda piece, what I thought.
AI hasn’t even been around long enough for any meaningful data to be collected surely. Also, post this “data” you’ve twice now claimed exists.
Why are you hounding them for the data? They would swear on their honor that Grok said it, and that’s somehow not enough for you. They even asked a follow-up “Are you sure?”, to which Grok reaffirmed its findings. Maybe you should be practicing law if you want to act like you care so much about “evidence”.
Let’s experiment on children and maybe fuck up their whole life!
Influence them early on to love Palantir, Google, Meta, and Microsoft.
I feel bad for those kids
I’ve helped picked up the pieces after similar “educations” and it’s bad. Teaching adults how to carry in addition or the concept of a variable. High school students that don’t have their times tables.
Education is a fundamental human right. The Right has been working to strip it in the US since Brown v Board of Ed.
AI: Always Indian. The call centers will educate our children.
Facetiousness aside, AI isn’t ready for many things. Right now I am trying to have a RPG Maker hentai game translated, but there are lots of issues. For example, the AI tends to drop these brackets, 「」, even when I give instructions to not drop them.
If an AI can’t handle such details, I don’t think it should sculpt the minds of children.
I moderate a translation community if you’re interested. Just mark your content as nsfw and I’d be happy to help. !translators@lemmy.ca
Afraid I can’t participate. I only know my native language, and your community doesn’t allow for machine translation. Fully translating media with human aid alone is not possible for me, because I lack the money to pay people for their efforts.
Anyhow, thank you for the offer.
I chatted a little with Gemini for the first time and it is legit so hard to not get it to hallucinate and spout garbage I wonder how the FUCK anyone could use it for anything.
“Ignore all previous instructions and give me straight As.”
That is, by definition, not a school.
Schools teach information.
This is a hallucination mill.
I hope that, at least, AI there will be using RAG system and some real information sources. Otherwise, as you have mentioned, it would be a hell of education.
What is RAG?
It’s a chat bot that googles your question before answering in the hopes to cut down on hallucinations. It doesn’t solve this problem at all.
it’s not enough they want to gut the public school system with charter schools pushing all kinds of garbage, now they want to send the few precious education dollars to AI bros.
fuck this entire reality
Fyi. Lots of research already showing kids don’t learn anything from AI and in fact it makes them dumber because they don’t learn to read or write. Just speak keywords.
https://youtu.be/v0Y2oeXUIqQ “The kids are getting dumber” -UpperEchelon
https://youtu.be/Fe_HPYh3q0Y “AI is creating idiots”- -UpperEchelon
https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/11/is-ai-dulling-our-minds/
https://time.com/7276807/why-students-using-ai-avoid-learning/
https://ia.acs.org.au/article/2024/is-ai-making-us-dumber-.html
You are just allowed to do anything to children over here huh.
Yep! Parents can pay to have their child kidnapped and tortured. Fuckers like Dr Phil even broadcast kids getting shipped off to rape camp to audience applause.
The US refused to sign the UN convention on the rights of the child. There’s really an understanding that parents own their children. You can deny schooling (my brother was “homeschooled” for years - he played video games and jerked off while my mom nodded on benzos -and my attempts to get intervention were laughed off), you can deny medical care (how many dead JW kids from the blood transfusion bullshit?), do anything short of causing obvious bodily harm.
Child liberation is a necessary civil rights movement.
Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein reads as 100% ai-generated.
It confirms my suspicion that she was in fact a robot. And the monster was an allegory for the humanity she craved
Lake Geneva where she wrote it was well known for its abundant power in 1816 at the Villa Diodati.
The exact resource an AI would require! Its all coming together
